First Communion: Mocking the Body of Christ

In the previous post I gave, to the best of my knowledge, the case for why Communion was reserved for those who are able to “discern” the body of Christ.  This traditional means that they are able to understand what they are doing when they receive Communion.

I will now give a different interpretation of those verses that I believe to be more correct.

The passage of scripture (1 Corinthians 11:27-30) must be seen in the wider context of the chapter in which the pericope begins, 1 Corinthians 11:17 and goes all the way to verse 34.  The first two verses are telling about what is going on. Paul writes,

 Now in the following instruction I do not commend you, because when you come     together it is not for the better but for the worse.  For, to begin with, when you come     together as a church, I hear that there are divisions among you; and to some extent I     believe it.  Indeed, there have been faction among you, for only so will will it become     clear who among you are genuine.  When you come together, it is not really to eat the     Lord’s supper. For when the time comes to eat, each of you goes ahead with your own     supper, and one goes hungry and another becomes drunk.  What! Do you not have homes to eat and drink in?  Or do you show contempt for the church of God and humiliate those who have nothing? (1 Corinthians 11:17-22)

This is what was going on in Corinth when they were getting together to have communion.  The divisions where economic and social.   The meal that was suppose to unite them with God and bind them as a community but it was actually dividing them. The poor where not eating and the rich where. Some where getting drunk.  After Paul teaches them the words of institution and warns them about discerning the body of Christ he writes:

So then, my brothers and sisters, when you come together to eat, wait for one another.  If you are hungry, eat at home, so that when you come together, it will not be for your condemnation. (1 Corinthians 11:33-34)

The real issue was about what people did when they came together for communion.  They where mocking communion by the divisions among them.  And because of that they where not taking serious what Christ had done for them in his death and resurrection. Richard Hays writes in the Interpretation Commentary:

Those who are failing to “discern the body” are those who act selfishly, focusing on their own spirituality and exercising their own social privileges while remaining heedless of those who share with them in the new covenant inaugurated by the Lord’s death. (pg. 200)

If we take serious the context around what Paul meant when he said we had to discern the body of Christ, we have to also recognize that these verses have nothing to do with children. Paul was concerned that they didn’t mock the sacrament, training our children in the way of Christ does the exact opposite. The way most people really learn something is by doing it.

What do you think?  Is there anything that you would contend with or add?

Leave a comment

Filed under Ministry Reflections

First Communion: Discerning the Body of Christ

The Biblical Case Against Communing Infants/Children

One of the most common explanations I hear why children should not partake of communion is because they are unable to “discern the body of Christ.” This phrase comes from 1 Corinthians 11:27-30.

Whoever, therefore, eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord in an unworthy manner will be answerable for the body and blood of the Lord.  Examine yourselves, and only then eat the bread and drink the cup.  For all who eat and rink without discerning the body, eat and drink judgment against themselves.

This seems to be the scriptural foundation on which not communing children until a certain “age of reason” when they are able to discern for themselves what they are doing. The appropriate age varies depending on the pastor and congregation and when they might deem that to be.

I think that this is a concern for some pastors and parents because they don’t want their children to, “eat and drink judgment on themselves.”  The logic then goes that they need some instruction on the real presence of Christ in communion so that they know what they are doing.  Todd W, Nichol in his essay Infant Communion in Light of the Lutheran Confessions writes, “Because Christ is really present in his Supper, worshipers always meet him there, either for judgment or blessing.”  He later writes, “It has only rarely been asked; ‘Can we expose [children] to the possibility not only of blessings so great, but judgment so severe?'”

Because of the traditional interpretation and the battles of real presence during the Reformation, it is understandable why this tradition continues.

For those of you who might hold to this view, do I have it right? Is there anything you would like to add in defense of this argument?  I’d be interested in your reasoning.

Next:  Other ways of reading this passage of scripture.

2 Comments

Filed under Ministry Reflections

First Communion: What Does Your Church Practice?

Lutheran churches today have a variety of practices concerning when children can receive communion.  I’ve seen everything from toddlers (those who can stick food in their mouths) all the way to the 5th grade.  Some congregations don’t have a set age when someone can receive communion and leave it up to the parents to discern when their child can receive.

There are a variety of levels of celebration which accompany first communion. I’ve seen it not be noted at all, being mentioned in the bulletin, to making a really big deal of it.  It seems that that the ELCA also recognizes this in its document Principles for Worship. Principle 37 says, “Admission to the Sacrament is by invitation of the Lord, presented through the church to those who are baptized.”  Principle 38 says, “Common mission among the congregations of this church depends on mutual respect for varied practice in many areas of church life including the ages of first Communion.” So in these two principles we have a common belief that the person should be baptized (I recognize this is not the case for some churches) and also that we respect the traditions of individual churches.

My question to you is this: When does your church practice first communion and why?  What is your theological rational for doing this? What scripture and confessional documents do you use to support your view?  In short, why do you do what you do?

(I am starting a series on first communion mainly to work out what I think.  I am not interested in this series in having the communion without baptism conversation)

2 Comments

Filed under Ministry Reflections

The Side Look

Many of you know that I am a twin.  Often, people ask questions that are well intentioned but not well thought out.  Questions like, “What’s it like being a twin?”  I would respond, “I don’t know, what’s it like not being a twin?”  This response is intended to expose that I don’t know what’s it’s like because I have nothing to compare it to.

There is also something that I have gotten used to and learned to easily recognize.  It’s “the side look.”  This is the look that someone gives me because they think they know me, but aren’t quit sure.  So, they pass buy me to get a closer look giving me “the side look.”  Another variation of the look is that people smile and realize that the blank stare in my eyes does not recognize them as a friend, because, well, their not. They know my brother not me. The smile then turns to confusion.

Often people don’t believe that I’m a twin. After I tell them, they act as if I’m joking, dismissing my comments and continuing with the place we met before, or picking up where a conversation left off.  For instance, a long time ago, I went to my brother’s church and the head pastor wanted to to talk to me about church business in the parking lot.  I told him that I was looking for Jeremy and he didn’t quit get that I wasn’t joking with him.

Some would think that I would get mad that people get me confused with my brother.  They think that I would get mad that they called me the wrong name. But, really, it’s never bothered me. It’s never been a detriment to my personal identity because there is another guy on this planet that looks exactly like me. In fact, he’s one of the best people I know.  I am honored to get confused for him.

I’ve learned over the years that when I am getting “the side look” to just introduce myself and be prepared to say things like, “No I’m really not joking. Yes, we really do look and sound alike” and, “I don’t know what’s it like not being a twin?”

Leave a comment

Filed under Personal

Why the Crucifixion? #proggod

Tony Jones challenged us to answer the question, “Why the Crucifixion?”  I think that there are two quotes that can sum it up better than I could.

The theology of the cross, which may be stimulated by a certain kind of anthropological pre-understanding, is nevertheless first of all a statement about God, and what it says about God is not that God thinks humankind so wretched that it deserves death and hell, but that God thinks humankind and the whole creation so good, so beautiful, so precious in its intentions and its potentiality, that its actualization,its fulfillment, its redemption is worth dying for.”

“The divine love that is ready to suffer birth in human form ‘must’ follow through, if it is really love for creatures, for us. It ‘must’ suffer life, not only birth; it ‘must’ suffer death, too.”

Douglas John Hall, “The Cross in our Context” (Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2003), pgs. 24, 28.

Leave a comment

Filed under Quotes

Books I Read In 2012

Broken: Seven Christian Rules That Every Christian Ought to Break as Often as PossibleTaking Theology to Youth MinistrySent and Gathered: A Worship Manual for the Missional ChurchCatch: Attracting and Connecting VisitorsWhat You Should Know about Politics... But Don't: A Nonpartisan Guide to the Issues

Paul and the New Perspective: Second Thoughts on the Origin of Paul's GospelThe Furious Longing of GodSustainable Youth Ministry: Why Most Youth Ministry Doesn't Last and What Your Church Can Do about ItBlue Like Jazz: Nonreligious Thoughts on Christian SpiritualityThe Hunger Games (The Hunger Games #1)

Catching Fire (The Hunger Games, #2)Mockingjay (The Hunger Games, #3)The Orthodox WayThe Future of LiberalismThe Art Of Manliness: Classic Skills And Manners For The Modern Man

What Would Jesus Deconstruct?: The Good News of Postmodernism for the Church (The Church and Postmodern Culture)Almost Christian: What the Faith of Our Teenagers Is Telling the American ChurchHow Children Succeed: Grit, Curiosity, and the Hidden Power of CharacterHow (Not) to Speak of God: Marks of the Emerging Church

 

Leave a comment

Filed under Book I've Read

Sermon: A Forgetful People (Luke 3:7-18)

Ever walked into a room and forgot why you where there?  Have no fear, it’s not you that’s the problem, it’s actually the doorway you’re entering through. Some psychologists at the University of Notre Dame have discovered that going through a doorway triggers what is known as an event boundary.  This event boundary separates one set of thoughts and memories from the next.  So when your walking through a door your brain files away old information to prepare for the new information.  Your brain resets itself to process new information.  So, if you walk into a room and forget why you are there, have no fear, it’s the doorway that is making you do it.
The reason I bring this up because but I think this highlights an even more important point; we are a forgetful people. We forget how good we have it, how fortunate we are to live in the town we do, to have the careers we have, to be able to be retired and not have to work anymore.  We forget the comfort in which we live and it takes a tragic event to jar us out of our forgetfulness.  I was confronted with this harsh reality when I heard about a shooting that took the lives of 27 people in Newtown, Connecticut, 20 of which were children.  Then I remember.  I find myself grateful once again for the life that I have and that this time the act of violence wasn’t toward me and my loved ones.  We are indeed a forgetful people.
We need to be reminded again and again why we are here, and who’s we are, and how to be in the world.  But this is nothing new, it has happened before, and it will happen again.  We forget and then remember in what is almost an endless cycle.  It’s as if our default position is amnesia.
We heard in today’s gospel reading John the Baptist s with words calling people to account for their lives. John the Baptist comes and tells people to take a good hard look at their complacency.  He says to them, “Don’t presume to say that we have Abraham as our ancestor’; for I tell you, God is able from these stones to raise children to Abraham.”  The people claimed that they a special relationship God through natural birth.  But then they had forgotten what that meant.  At another place Jesus picks up this same issue and says, “If Abraham were your father you would be doing what Abraham did”  But they weren’t doing what Abraham did, they had forgotten.
People started to ask John the Baptist, What shall we do then?  How do we remember?  How is it that we live out who god has called us to be?  Repent and be baptized. See a long time ago the people of Israel had undergone a baptism.  They went through the waters of the Jordan as slaves of Egypt and came out free.  John was calling them to do the same.  Go into the waters as slaves of complacency and forgetfulness and come out again ready to be involved what God was doing in the world. John was telling the people who were coming out to be baptized by him.  The people who were already wanting something new.  This baptism was repenting of there sins and living into the new reality of God’s coming reign.
But they asked him what shall we do?  He tell tells them.  If you have two coats give one away.  If you have food give half of that away.  He tells tax collectors not to steal from the people and soldiers to be satisfied with their pay and not extort money from the people they were supposed to be protecting.  He tells them to do what they already knew was the right thing to be doing.  John was telling them to bear the fruit that was already being produced inside of them.  They needed to be reminded how to be in the world after they had undertaken this new baptism, this new exodus from their former slavery.
I have heard all over the news these last few days, “What shall we do?” How shall we live after this tragedy?” And naturally it turns to politics.   Stricter Gun Control Laws? Less strict laws? Armed police in every school? There are no easy political answers.  How are we to be a people together after such a tragedy has taken place?  We are jarred from our complacency and realize that we need some answers we need to remember who we are.  And it’s hard to do after a tragedy.
But there was also someone in the news this week that did not forget who she is.  The very day that the shooting happened in Connecticut, a Woman in Virginia by the name of Stacey Jackson was having a memorial service at Oakwood Baptist Church for her son Jerry Brown. Jerry and his friend Josh Brent play for the Dallas Cowboys. Jerry was killed in a car accident and it is suspected that his team mate Joshua is to blame for the accident. He drove drunk with Jerry in the car that ended up upside down on the freeway and it cost Jerry his life.  Stacey Jackson had an amazing response to Josh Brent, she insisted that they ride to the funeral together, she wanted them to mourn together.  She told one news organization, “I just told him keep his head up, we’re praying for him. And I still love him; he can call me at 4:00 in the morning; he can call me at 12:00 crying. I don’t care. Because Jerry loved him like a brother.”  Even though Josh may go to jail, Stacey is standing by his side.  She has forgiven him and has brought him closer into her family.
At a time of tragedy she has taken a different road.  She is not shouting for vengeance and stricter DUI laws and the evils of Alcohol.  She is doing what she knows.  She is being a mother.  She is forgiving.  She is loving. Even loving the man who took her sons life.         Not long ago there was another school shooting in Pennsylvania.  On October 3, 2006 a man named Charles Roberts, age 32, took a small Amish schoolhouse hostage in Nickel Mines, Pennsylvania. He had walked in there with guns and rope, intending to do very bad things to the students.  After he tied them up, the oldest girl student knew what was coming and told Roberts, “shoot me first.” Her sister said, “Shoot me second.”  They had hoped to buy time for the other students.   Roberts killed 10 people that day not including himself.
And when I had first heard about this shooting my blood began to boil at the injustice, the pain, and the suffering that this man had caused. But this community had a different response.  One woman was going around to the students and was telling them, “We must not think evil of this man.”  In the moment of pain and suffering she was training them in Christ.  Another man said telling people, “He had a mother and a wife and a soul and now he is standing before God.”  I saw a news report that asked a man in the community how he felt about Roberts. He said with tears in his eyes, “I have already forgiven him in my heart.” But it didn’t end there either.  This community didn’t just forgive this man, they sought reconciliation with Roberts widow, parents, and in-laws. Maria Roberts the widow was one of the few outsiders invited to the funeral. The Amish, who are not accustomed to taking donations, helped set up a fund for the Widow and diverted some of the donations they received to her.
Some thought they were foolish to forgive. Others had a different explanation. One author wrote, “that the Amish willingness to forgo vengeance does not undo the tragedy or pardon the wrong, but rather constitutes a first step toward a future that is more hopeful.”  Jesus said to his disciples, “If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them; if you retain the sins of any, they are retained.”  Yes, we need to remember how to forgive. We need to practice forgiving and loving and learning what it means to be a Spirit filled people. So that, like this community, who underwent a tragedy more profound than words can describe their forgiveness is etched into their own bodies as the nails in Christ hand and feet- and the world took notice. In 2006 there were news programs, magazine articles, documentaries done on the Amish community because of the way they followed Jesus.
What if after this tragedy in Connecticut we also talked about forgiveness?  What if we talked about faith and hope and love?  What if we talked about holding those people with mental illnesses, those people who are on the outskirts of our society, those who are unloved, even closer?
I believe in hope.  I believe in a day when sin will be no more, when all injustices will be made just.  I believe in a day when there will be no sorrow and every tear will be wiped away from our eyes.  There will be a day when the reign of God will encompass all of the earth. and the lion shall lie down with lamb and peace, true peace, will be known.  I am filled with expectation this advent season that Jesus will return one day and make all things right again.  Amen.

Leave a comment

Filed under Sermons

Worship: My Heart isn’t in It

I used to believe that when at worship on Sunday morning I had to have this intense experience in the singing.  Just singing the words was not enough, I had to feel them, it had to come from the depths of my being.  As time passed, if I didn’t have this experience at worship, I felt like there was something wrong with my relationship with God. I felt like I had to conjure up this thing inside of me to “feel” the worship if my heart was not in it.  Even just being open, if nothing happened, I felt like there was something wrong with me.  I prayed earnestly for this experience to happen.

Since leaving these forms of worship I have come to a different place in my understanding of worship.  My heart isn’t always in it but the liturgy always holds me. Sometimes I am just going through the motions.  But that is absolutely OK.  My being at worship doesn’t depend on my feelings, but God’s faithfulness.  The liturgy holds me because it isn’t about what I do, but who God is, and how God relates to me.  Through the proclamation of God’s saving grace in Jesus (Word) and through the visible Word of God (Sacrament), I am given the grace and strength to know that my faith doesn’t depend on my feelings at worship, but on a Jesus who is for me.

Now this is not to say that I don’t find myself moved at worship. Sometimes the songs or the words we hear move me, because it relates God’s unrelenting love for me. Sometimes I start to tear up or really experience it in the depths of my being.  But, I don’t always have these intense feelings at worship. It’s just like I am not always overcome by intense feelings when I tell my children I love them. But they do need to hear it and I need to say it.

1 Comment

Filed under Ministry Reflections

Parenting as a Spiritual Discipline: Worship and Children with Differing Needs

During thanksgiving I had a hankering for some BBQ and Phil’s BBQ in Santee was the place to go. We met some friends that we hadn’t seen in a while and they brought their child who has been diagnosed on the autism spectrum, specifically, Pervasive Developmental Disorder (PDD).
This child did a great job in the loud restaurant. He wore headphones the whole time to help with noise and spent his time occupied with Star Wars Legos. Every once and a while he stopped and we fist bumped. That’s how I roll. These parents needed to bring there son, because he won’t stay with anyone else, we convinced our children to stay home, as they were tired and whiny. I thought it would be a better experience for all of us if they just spent time with their Noni and Papi.

Toward the end of our time together I asked them if they had a congregation they were worshiping with. What they told me was an interesting perspective that I have not had to think about.

If they go to a church where the worship is loud (i.e. Praise Band), then the noise could greatly disturb their son. If they go to a church that is more traditionally liturgical, then the times of quite could turn into large outbursts for whatever reason. Both types of churches brought potential risks.

This particular child needs to be with his mom. He is not able to go to the nursery or even be handled by his father, without mom being close at hand. If they go to a cry room there is a potentially volatile situation because there are more kids freaking out, potentially causing this child to also freak out.

Most of the time they opt to just not attend worship because of the potential mine fields for their child.

Being a pastor, I asked what could churches do to accommodate children with differing needs. Their response was this, “Be OK with a loud child in church.” It’s that simple.

Often we don’t know why a child is loud in church. But, it’s important that both parents and child are there. We need to make room for children, all children, to be in worship.

 

Leave a comment

Filed under Ministry Reflections, Parenting

On Vacationing as a Pastor

One of the things that surprises me so much about being a pastor is how many plates I have spinning at once. I am starting to consider this an art rather than worry. With that being said, it’s hard taking a vacation. Plates don’t stop spinning when I go on vacation. I find myself thinking about those in need in my parish. I find myself strategizing for the year still. I am only two days into this vacation and I am already thinking about what I have to do when I get back. Being called into the ministry is beautiful and scary experience. Beautiful because I love what I do. Scary because it’s on my mind all the time.
Hopefully I practice the discipline of being fully present during my vacation and hopefully everywhere. The benefit is giving my total attention to what’s in front of me.

2 Comments

Filed under Ministry Reflections